This post is another one of my sermons – this one preached just before Christmas at our church. It’s based on Matthew 1:18-25, the story of Joseph’s reaction to Mary’s pregnancy and the angelic visitor. There is lots that could be said, both about Joseph, and about the names the baby will have, but here is where I focused:
Silent Night. Holy Night. All is calm, all is bright. I love the carol – but it sounds so peaceful and calm, and well, slightly unrealistic. And then there is the reality that our world feels very far from the calmness of that carol – which brings to mind another rendition of the carol that you might know. It’s from Simon and Garfunkel, and it’s the carol set with the news headlines in the background.
In the 1960s that was the vietnam war, racial tension and various other issues – but it’s not difficult to imagine a similar set of headlines for today: Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Israel’s attacks on Gaza, China’s threats in the Pacific – the list could go on.
The question is: do those ongoing traumatic headlines destroy the reality of the carol? Does the darkness of this world mean Christmas is a nice idea without any real power? What use is this message in a world of such darkness?
Well we’ll see this morning that it makes all the difference in the world. That we have a God who rescues us, and comes to be with us.
His rescue and his presence mean we do not need to fear to step forward with him in whatever situation we find ourselves, in the midst of our ordinary lives.
Today’s story wraps up the gift of God’s salvation and God’s presence in the story of an ordinary couple living in the midst of times much like ours – full of darkness, full of wicked rulers and people struggling under tyranny, and people struggling just to make ends meet.
We’ll start with the first part of the wrapping in Matthew 1:18-19 – please have the bibles open in front of you.
This passage comes at the end of the long list of names at the start of Matthew’s gospel which form Matthew’s introduction to the story of how Jesus came. The names remind us that Jesus is the son of David, the son of Abraham and of God’s promises to Israel.
God’s people at this point were waiting for the promised Son of David, a King like David who would give them freedom from their enemies. They lived under the rule of the Romans – Herod, King of Judea ruled as a Roman king, giving allegiance to Caesar as his overlord, keeping a wary eye on any who might be seen as a messiah.
It was a tense time to be a Jew – waiting, longing for deliverance and freedom – yet fearing the next reinforcement of Roman rule. We might expect God’s next move to be in the palaces of the mighty. The Jews of Jesus’ day would have expected some kind of mighty act of God’s power.
And yet God’s deliverance begins with an ordinary engaged couple in an ordinary small town. Joseph is a carpenter, maybe originally from Bethlehem finding work in Nazareth to ply his trade – perhaps just starting out on his own.
Mary and Joseph are likely young – their families would have likely arranged the marriage – perhaps Joseph had noticed Mary, but maybe it was entirely set up. He would have been a bit older than her, but we don’t know how much older – we know he fades out of the story – and isn’t mentioned later on in the gospels – but all that might mean is that he got ill and died young. We just aren’t told.
They are engaged to be married. That means all the arrangements for the wedding had been made, the families had agreed how it would all work, and for a period of time the couple were promised to each other, but still lived separately – to break off the engagement was to divorce.
No doubt Joseph was looking forward to the day of the wedding, to life with his bride, and to the family line continuing. But into this happy expectation comes the realisation that all is not well. Mary is pregnant. And he is not the father. We don’t know how he knows of the pregnancy. Does he know directly from Mary? Has she gone directly to explain? Or, perhaps more likely, has he found out via the families? Has news reached him via an aunt, or a cousin? Has he just been told that Mary has gone out of town to Elizabeth, her miraculously pregnant older cousin?
We don’t know what Joseph knows – just that stark, unarguable reality: she is pregnant, and he is not the father. He is a “righteous” man – a law upholding man, one who wants to do the right thing. And he also is a compassionate man – he doesn’t want to drag her into the public square, and shame her as an adulteress. So a quiet divorce is the way forward – perhaps he can simply let her stay with her cousin, safely out of the way until a child is born and something worked out with the father – whoever he might be. Unless the father is married to someone else. Then that would truly be messy – but surely Mary would never do that?
Joseph’s world is upside down, his mind in turmoil. His thoughts racing. Into this confusion and turmoil in this night comes a dream.
In this dream the angel says: Joseph, son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife. To take Mary as his wife is to take on some disgrace – it will be obvious the baby has come too soon. His reputation as righteous will be over – or else the whispers that he has been cheated on and is weak will grow. He has reputational damage to fear. He has how Mary thinks about him to fear – does she really love another rather than him?
So to not fear he needs to heed the words of the angel: do not be afraid. Do not be afraid to take Mary. And as we look at what the angel says, we will see two key reasons not to be afraid in the names Jesus is given. Jesus, and Immanuel.
To us names might not seem that important or indeed accurate. For example my names are: Mark – warlike, Paul – little, Arnold – “eagle power” – so a small, but powerful warrior maybe?! But in the bible the meanings of names tell us a lot about the people involved (e.g. Jacob = grasper). And Jesus means “Yahweh (the Hebrew’s name for God) rescues,” and Immanuel means “God is with us”
So first of all: do not be afraid because Jesus rescues
Joseph is told not to be afraid because the baby is no ordinary child. The baby is from the Holy Spirit, and the baby is to be called Jesus.
Jesus, which means Yahweh rescues –the name Yahweh was revealed to Moses when God rescued the Israelites out of Egypt, fulfilling his promise to Abraham. It is the covenant name of God, the name of the God who makes and keeps his promises to his people. The baby is to be called Jesus because he will rescue his people from their sins.
It is not simply that God will rescue his people – although that is true. But Jesus will rescue his people. Matthew is telling us that Jesus is in reality not simply God’s rescuer, or even God’s king – but is God himself. Jesus is God come to rescue his people.
But he is not simply a rescuer from their oppressors. He hasn’t come to overthrow the Romans as the Jews were hoping. No, Jesus comes to rescue his people from their sins.
Why did God’s people in Matthew’s day – and why do we today need to be rescued from our sin?
Well, the story of God’s people in the OT is a story of repeated deliverances followed by falling back into sin, and facing the consequences of those sins and the punishment for those sins. It seems they could be delivered from a horrible situation – like slavery in Egypt, but much more was needed to get the wrong patterns of life out of them. God’s people need a way to be delivered not simply from external oppressors but from sin.
And the same is true for us? How often do we excuse wrong patterns in our life – of deeds, words or behaviour by an “if only.” If only such and such a circumstance changed I wouldn’t do such and such a sin? It would be much easier to be patient if I didn’t have to work for a boss like that! I could be so much less angry if my children didn’t argue back, or if my spouse just understood what I wanted them to do and did it.
Then sometimes perhaps the circumstances do change, we get a different job but still get impatient. We still get angry. We still snap at others. We still create the same kind of relational issues.
Our deepest problem is not the external circumstances, but the sin that lives in our hearts. The sin that doesn’t simply drag down our own well being and our relationships with others, but which keeps us from God, which leads to our separation from God and being cut off from his restoration of all things in the future. We, like God’s people then, need a way to be rescued from sin.
And that is what Jesus comes to do – by his death on the cross he will take away God’s anger at our sin, and open the way for us to come back to God – if we will put our trust in him. He will rescue his people from their sin – all who trust in what he has done. But, as Jesus’ words later in Matthew will remind us, for those who refuse to welcome this newborn king into their lives there is no salvation, only final exclusion from all that is good and right when Jesus returns to reign – as we’ve learnt in the parables of Jesus in recent family services.
When we hear this name “Jesus” we need to remember all this – he is called this because he is God who came down to rescue us from our deepest problem – sin. And so there is no need to be afraid. But there is a deeper reason not to be afraid in the next part of Matthew’s story:
Do not be afraid: God is with you – 22-23
This, we will see, is even more amazing than God’s desire to rescue us. And to see this we have to see the story that Isaiah told, that Matthew shows Jesus fulfilling. Which is why I wanted to have the Isaiah reading too – and why the people who put the lectionary together included this reading for us.
Because when Matthew quotes OT passages and says that Jesus fulfilled them he isn’t taking those words from the OT and twisting them to fit his story. No. What he is doing is reminding his readers that Jesus’ story fulfills the OT story of Israel and by quoting these verses from Isaiah he reminds his Jewish Christian readers of the whole section that those words in Isaiah 7 are a part of.
Maybe think of it like this. If we hear the words “We shall fight them on the beaches” we don’t just think of a battle on a beach – we think of the whole wartime spirit of defiance against tyranny and for freedom that Churchill’s wartime speeches conjure up.
To understand this Emmanuel reference properly we need to go back to Isaiah’s prophecy. In that reading Isaiah was talking to King Ahaz – a king of Judah who worshipped idols and feared invasion from two kingdoms to his north. Despite that God had not given up on Judah and gave Ahaz a sign to encourage him to trust in God – and also to act as a warning.
The sign is that a virgin will be with child and give birth to a son Immanuel – and before that child is old enough to be accountable for their actions the kingdoms opposed to Ahaz will be removed. In Isaiah’s context that simply means someone who is a young woman is about to become pregnant and have a child. The child will be called Immanuel – God is with us – to remind Ahaz and Judah that God is with his people.
Furthermore the story does not stop there. In Isaiah 8 Isaiah has a son, and we wonder could this be the one? Is this Immanuel? Isaiah’s son is given a different name – “Quick to the plunder, swift to the spoil” – which is related to the fact that God is going to judge the kingdoms to the north by Assyria. But in Isaiah’s prophecy God makes it clear that judgement will go on to Judah – and the prophecy of judgement against God’s people finishes with a cry of: “Immanuel” – God is with us.
Because if God’s people won’t trust in God, then God’s presence stops being a comfort and becomes a sign of judgment. If we won’t trust God, then God being with us is dangerous. But, the prophecy continues, if we do trust God then no plan formed against us can stop him – and again finishes with a cry of “God is with us – Immanuel”
Then Isaiah’s prophecy goes on to talk of an end to darkness. In famous words from Isaiah 9 we read of a child to be born who will be Wonderful Counsellor, Mighty God. What starts off as a simple prophecy of a child who gives a timeframe for God’s judgement becomes a prophecy of a child who will dispel darkness and reign as God on David’s throne.
In Isaiah these ideas all belong together, so when Matthew tells us Jesus fulfills these words about a virgin being with child he wants us to think of this whole sequence, and how Jesus brings out the whole meaning of it.
Jesus is the child born of a virgin. Jesus is the child who not only is a sign of God’s presence, but in himself is God with us. Jesus is the one by whom we stand or fall.
If Jesus is with us, then nothing can ultimately harm us. Jesus is the one who dispels the darkness and gloom, and who brings in the light of God’s rule. Jesus is the true Son of David who rules as no merely human king can. Jesus brings out the fulness of what Isaiah points to. Isaiah himself could only look on and wonder at how the fulness of what he was talking about would come to be – but Jesus shows us how it all fits together in him.
Jesus is God with us. God come among us. This is the news of Christmas. This is the fundamental reason for Jesus coming. Because God has not given up on his creation. The whole story of the Bible is about how God wants to live with his people – but the sin of his people means that they cannot bear his presence.
Jesus comes to deal with our sin, so that he can live among us. He comes by his Spirit now to live with us – and one day he will come again to put everything wrong right, to make everything sad come untrue and to give us new life with him on this earth restored and made new.
Immanuel means that God has not given up on this place. He has not abandoned us here and now. It means that above all else God wants to be with us. He wants to be with me and he wants to be with you. Salvation is not about simply avoiding judgement and being lifted out of the mess that this world is so often in. Salvation is about God coming down into the mess to be with us as he goes about his work of clearing up this mess and as he calls us to join him in that work.
Immanuel means that God becomes one of us, so that we might become like him. Our lives matter to him. The daily choices we make matter. The stuff we make and create things from matters. Our jobs, our families, our gardens, our kitchens, our workshops – all of these things matter to God.
And so we come back to Joseph and his obedience. We come back to the wrapping of ordinary life. If God had just wanted to save us he could have just appeared. He could have bypassed Joseph. He could have done it some other way. But God wanted to be with us. God wanted us to save us so that we could know him. And so God had to experience the whole of our lives. And so he needed Joseph to step up and play his part.
Joseph wakes up from the dream and he has to decide. Will he trust the angel? Will he give way to fear? Joseph is a righteous man. He knows his law. He knows the OT stories. He knows the family tree we’ve read and he knows the stories of: Tamar, Rahab, Ruth & Bathsheba – to the ways in which two of them were mistreated by men – and the way in which Ruth in particular was protected and cherished by Boaz. Joseph is being given a choice. Will he join Boaz as a man of strength, who uses his strength to protect and nurture?
Sometimes in the Christmas story we miss this particular challenge. The challenge to men of how we will behave. Of how we will use strength. The Herods of our day seem to dominate. And men seem to become either Herods, or Herod followers – those who enable wrong to be done and covered up. In the midst of such men comes the example of Joseph. The example of using strength to protect and cherish and keep safe. Throughout this story – read on into chapter 2, Joseph – like Boaz before him – is the protector for mother and baby. He obeys God and adopts the baby as his own.
He takes Mary as his wife. He chooses a way that would lead to comment. The marriage comes forward and everyone knows that there is a child on the way. “Righteous” Joseph, perhaps not quite so good now in everyone’s eyes.
And he doesn’t have sex with Mary until the baby is born. I think we’re told this to emphasize that Joseph knows that it isn’t about him at this point. Mary is pregnant – with the Son of God – and it needs to be absolutely clear to Mary and Joseph that the child is God’s child.
And yet the child is also Joseph’s because when the child is born Joseph names him Jesus – Joseph chooses the name. Joseph is adopting this child as his. Jesus was a Son of David because Joseph chose to include him.
God’s salvation plan comes to us, not with a huge fanfare. Not with a mighty army. Not with an impressive king, but with one young man wrestling with his future, hearing in a dream, and stepping forward in obedience. And that’s how he carries on working. Jesus’ plan to bring salvation to the nations, to bring God’s presence to all peoples, is worked out at the end of Matthew’s gospel in his disciples going and teaching all nations to obey – and knowing that Jesus is with them as they do that.
This Christmas there are no doubt any number of ways we need to obey God in our lives. And there are any number of ways we might fear to do what he wants. Fear can stop us doing something out of the ordinary. Fear can stop us from obeying the next step.
God’s call is not to be afraid. God’s call is to remember that Jesus has come to save us from our sin, and God’s call is to remember that Jesus is God with us. There is no need to let fear have the last word – instead we step forward in faith, trusting God’s promise and looking to work with him in the restoration of this world.



